Working towards true accountability

Online media is often touted as being a completely accountable medium, however I would disagree, online is certainly more accountable than above the line, and the availability of metrics allows marketers and their agencies access to a bevy of data that they previously only dreamed of. However a major issue for me personally (and I would hope others also) is that a lot of these metrics designed to bring about clarity only really serve to cloud the waters further.

Let’s look at some common metrics and the associated issue that I personally see.

Impressions – Impressions are deceptive because if your ad serves below the fold then your ad may in fact never have met eyeballs, yet it counts the same as an ad that is front and centre. (This extend through to some of the rich media engagement metrics which I will look at a bit later)

Clicks – Clicks are deceptive in that when a client pays for a click they assume they are paying for traffic to their sites, however I have seen drop offs of in excess of 50% of clicks not landing on the assigned landing page. This means that although a user clicked on a banner they closed the browser that opened before it had time to load the landing page.

Unique Browsers/Users – Here is a term that is much hated by many in the industry. It is entirely inaccurate, but with that said no more so than any of the metrics applied to above the line media. The primary arguments here are around cookie deletion and users who browse on multiple computers. These combined factors mean that the unique reach metric is actually a rather soft one.

And moving on to some of the engagement metrics that rich media is reporting we see similar issues to those listed above.

Rich media time on screen – This is that same as an impression, however the name is deceptive because it is counting the time on page, not on screen. You could spend 20 minutes on the top half of a screen while an ad you can’t see is counting this as “on screen” time.

Finding a solution to these issues isn’t going to be easy and it isn’t going to come anytime soon. For one thing I think if we found a way to only cookie users to whom the ad actually displayed on screen it would face serious opposition from publishers as it would drastically reduce their available inventory.

I know Ben Shepherd talks about the issues surrounding the streamlining of online measurement and it’s relationship with above the line measurement frequently over at Talking Digital but what are your thoughts on this? Has anyone heard of a technology that allows for a cookie to drop only when an ad is visible to a user?


5 thoughts on “Working towards true accountability

  1. Has anyone heard of a technology that allows for a cookie to drop only when an ad is visible to a user?

    No – but gee it would be good if this became available. We’ve been asking EB/Atlas for years to try and do this – still no movement 😦

  2. I’ve also asked several of the adservers whether they are looking into it and they have always said they’re not. It seems like it should be possible…

  3. I’m doing a bit of research for this ad viewed on screen. I work for Facilitate Digital and we have run this for a few clients, we can report on the time an ad was actually visible on screen (well we break it down to a set of seconds and tell you how many ads fall in to each of these – the time periods are customizable). This works well except for ads in iframes, so we count those separately.

    has anybody come across another company that can do this? I’d like to see what other options we can offer with it – or if you are interested in this you may want to contact your friendly Facilitate Digital rep.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s